Hey guys so last night I hooked up with the girl next door. She has been all over me at parties in the past but we never really did anything until yesterday. The complication is that she has a boyfriend back in her home town.

So we watch a movie, start cuddling and making out. A few times she said that she had a boyfriend and I just ignored it and kept making out with her. Eventually she helps me slide her pants off and we have sex. Midway through she gets up and grabs a condom for me and we keep going. We had sex again after that, which she initiated. She was all over me after and telling me how much she liked me and shit.

That night she texted me and said she felt horrible for cheating. I said we can talk tomorrow because I have an exam at 8am and need sleep. So now it’s tomorrow and she sent me messages implying that she didn’t give consent and that her boyfriend is coming. I don’t care about the boyfriend but how should I handle this?

Her messages were saying she thought we were just friends and that she didn’t want to have sex and told me no when I was taking off her pants, which isn’t true. She was very clearly consenting. The only times she resisted anything was when she said she had a boyfriend and then saying that she “isn’t easy”.

What should I say when I talk to her?

Update: I just knocked on her door to get my glasses and there were two older people in there who are either her parents or her roommates. I just said nevermind and left when they answered. Now I’m freaking out. Should I just have my roommate get my glasses?