I get enough matches on dating apps which usually lead to an in-person meeting/drinks. Some of these go really well and involve a fair amount of intimacy.

What happens next is that I almost never get a relationships/hookup or even a second date because it fizzles out pretty quick. 1 in 3 women have explicitly stated we have no chemistry irrespective of how much we made out in the bar on the first date.

I suspect I'm messing up my follow-ups (either too much or none).

I could use some advice on how to make something more out of a great first date?