I have completely moved away from Online Dating. I get very few matches and most either flake or never respond. I exclusively go to clubs and music festivals and I feel I do way better there in terms of getting several numbers and getting way more responses than dating apps.

The last 12+ girls I've texted(dating apps, clubs, music festivals), I've had zero success in ever meeting them! Even with the girls I've made out within the club, who offered to give me their number/Snapchat -- they either flake(which I'm ok with) but somehow, the conversation starts on a high/funny note, and they pretty much ghost or come up with an excuse if I ask them on a date. I can put up many examples here:

Girl 1 - Matched on Bumble. This was in Feb/March when I was an absolute idiot. She used pickup lines on me, we talked for a few weeks. Then I eventually proposed a stupid idea for the first date - "Stargazing in a location, 1.5 hours away, in the dark). Even though I had established a connection, it was a ridiculous idea and by then, she had probably lost interest Lesson - Be quick to move from text to date, suggest something simple for the first date, don't invest more than she does

Girl 2 - Matched on Bumble. Pretty quickly moved from text to phone number(previous was all on Bumble). I made her guess that she needs to give me my number(very indirectly) and it was on a good note. Took about a week of texting to ask if "she's ever been to Ice skating" because the convo was leading up to a date(time free etc.). And just like that, bam! NO RESPONSE!I texted her over a month ago, after I was quite free, to see if she was still interested in going out(shoot your shot!). She replied, said "Yes", and after 2-3 texts. Gone again.

I have no idea how I botched this

Girl 3 - Matched on Tinder. SHE texted me first complimenting my bio and pics. Same as above -- quickly moved to IG. We even developed some connection, supporting each other. Couldn't meet because both of us were super busy. It could have been about a month of texting. I had to go on a 7 day vacation, informed about it to her. I came back and asked her if she wanted to go out now. The response I got was "Hey, you are a really nice guy, but I am not looking to date anyone now!"This felt like a lot of wasted time and I gave up on dating apps. I feel I do WAY better IRL

Girl 4 - Friend of a friend, but lives in a city 3 hours by flight. Very flirty on the first meet. Seemed very into me, I even asked when I can take her out again. They were supposed to come to where I live, the next week, and so she suggested then! But unfortunately, they missed their flight and lost an entire day here. I could just meet the group, and that was a lost opportunity. After that, I went to her city, and seeing my Instagram status, she texted me asking if I'm there. Most obvious signs of interest. Since I was roaming around, I didn't text much and once I was done, I texted her if she's free for the next 2 days and I got a "she's busy and will have to meet me some other time". Another one down the drainLesson - Other than delayed responses to her delayed responses, I don't think I did anything wrong here. I polarized immediately when she showed obvious signs of interest.

Girl 5 - Made out with a girl in a nightclub. It was amazing! I asked if we could "go back to my place". She gave me her number and left. I text her the next day asking what she is doing the weekend. No response. I double texted her, just in case, close to the weekend if she is free. No responseLesson - Club makeouts/ number closes probably doesn't mean anything.

Girl 6 - Different club. Just was into me the whole time. No makeout but she couldn't let go of me. Number close, no responseLesson - Club number close probably means diddly-squat

Girl 7 - Same as above. Messaged me back that she's coming to same club. We met there, she hugged me and then said "Bye" and went away. Jesus Christ!

Girl 8 and 9. This is the craziest story(for me!). I was just dancing with my friend when a girl(let's call A) saw me, grabbed me, and made out with me. Almost biting my lips off. This took maybe 5 seconds from seeing her to having her tongue down my throat. That was awesome. A minute later, I'm making out with her friend(let's call her B) and my lips are about to bleed from aggressive biting because I consciously denied her a kiss and she got mad(in a good way) and became very aggressive(again, in a good way). After a while, back to A. Then back to B. Both gave me their snap.

A - A started talking with me on snap, she sent the first message. Said she's going on a vacation for her birthday and "Do you want to join? :wink:". I played cool and suggested we(alone) could go a little earlier. She shot it down and suggested we could go elsewhere. I pivoted and a day later(I let her give me some time to decide) I suggested a bar date and I got an "I'm busy this week, I'm sorry". To top it all off, she somehow got hold of my IG and has sent me a follow request. Clearest signs of indication, and I'm quite sure the convo is not dead yet. I sent her a "Let me know when you are free the next week" and she acknowledged. That's where it's at now.Have I screwed this one up?

B - I'm also texting B at the same time, and I feel we're vibing. But its A who showed the clearest indication on going out with me/hooking up with me, and I got an "I'm busy this week" without rescheduling, which usually means not interested right? Anyways, I'm texting B now and see where it leads to.Should I avoid texting friends at the same time?

Girl 10 - Again, made out at a club. She was VERY into me! She said "You smell good" and started kissing/sucking my neck. It felt VERY sensual and awesome(I'm still on a 2+ year dry spell though!) She gave me her snap but I'm yet to text anything because I'm not sure she even remembers and at this point, I'm quite tired

Girl 11 - A girl, her friend, my friend, and I were in the same room at my friend's place. We just met at the club and went back to my friend's place. She was totally into me, bring her mouth close to me and pull away, laughing at even stupid things, playfully beating me, one time just hugged me and slept on me. Clearest IOIs. BUT I COULDN'T escalate at all as I felt weird doing it in front of friends. Later early morning, she called me "real amigo" when we went in search of her car(forgot the parking spot). Did I just get friend-zoned? This will suck. I have her number and we'll very likely hang out and I would be cool to hang out as friends, but I definitely want to believe I didn't blow up any chance I had.

Girl 12 - Met at a music festival, vibed, got her number and text "Hey this is ...". No response. The following weekend, I texted her "I'm going out tonight with my friends. Wanna join?". No response, but the next morning, she texted back saying she has gone to attend another festival in another city, and thanked me for inviting. Do I still have any chance?

So many interactions than I thought I could but I feel like I'm messing up everything. What can I do?