I'm new to spinning plates, and currently have 3 girls that I'm seeing. They all live in different cities, so it works well.

1 and 2 are totally solid. I have no doubts that they are mine. However, I think I may have messed up with #3.

She's my favorite of the 3. Smart, motivated, but from the beginning she was asking about other girls. The first night I met her, she asked how many girls I had met that night. After a couple of weeks of me casually playing things off, teasing her etc, she found out about girl 1.

Figuring it was better to be honest than lie, I told her about girl 1, and she eventually found out about girl 2. She doesnt know anything but names.

She was very upset (we still had sex after), but I did my best to maintain frame and explain that I'm a man who enjoys the company of women, but I like her and if she wants something different from another guy I respect that.

Anyway, she seemed pretty upset. I want to maintain a relationship if possible but more importantly I don't want to hurt her as she really is a sweet girl. Your advice is appreciated.