So long story short I go on a date with a girl, she's pretty cute but I don't feel like I'm 100% in being attracted to her physically compared to say other girls I've dated. However, I really enjoy her personality and we have good chemistry etc.

In this kind of situation, at what point are you being too picky vs settling for less? I mean as women get older and if you're dating someone seriously you will both not be as physically attractive as time passes. So having a mindset where you weigh heavily on attractiveness sounds like it will set you up for some terrible relationships in the long term. How does one even learn to put their mindset to focus more on personality over physical looks? Is this the right attitude?