There are a few guys in my college that would undoubtedly be 'chads' by the definition. When they talk with other girls that they've never met before, these girls respond to them in a really nice manner and kind of respect them, let them touch, etc..

These people aren't really handsome by face or look like a male model, just a bit above average. Even I have a similar build and appearance as these guys but I never get the same reaction from girls. Why's this so and how would possibly I get the same reactions?

I mean the whole AF/BB thing would make sense when you interact with a girl through words, but these girls who don't even know these chads respond to them so well. Just confuses me so bad making me think I have some invisible marker over me that reads BETA that I can't see..