Little backstory:

I was once the fat nerdy kid who entered puberty really late, was socially awkward yadda yadda yadda

I started working out and improving myself and my confidence grew and I started getting a lot of female attention (they saw me as someone who was successful but quietly self-assured and down to earth) and this sorta boosted my confidence further and there are those who would consider me arrogant...

seriously

and a lot of girls were once into me seem to criticise me for this and tell me I'm too egotisical, too competitive and too self-absorbed and never really have time for them and they are genuinely turned off by this. Honestly, it's completely natural too when I go out and interact with people, and my male friends are genuinely pleased for me. Do I actually need to tone it down around women?