I'm a successful musician, well respected and known in my community, lots of social proof. I am reasonably fit, groomed, dressed, attractive, and generally take good care of myself. Last night I played two shows, one sold out, one almost sold out. Seemed like the waitress was giving me glances and flirty looks all night. Ended up chatting her up briefly after the show, asked her if she'd like to connect when we both weren't working. She said "Yes!" in what seemed like an enthusiastic way. I gave her my phone to put her contact info in. Text her when I got home so she had my number. And then nothing today. Crickets. I stupidly followed up with a concrete day I was asking her out for. It was 18 hours later, but still a double text. Of course, nothing. This same scenario has happened a few times now. The stuff I read on this sub mentions skills, personality, charisma, social proof. I have had that going for me, and still no results. I signed up for dating coaching. They've just told keep doing what I'm doing its a numbers game, and not to personalize the rejection. But Ive literally never succeeded irl/off apps. And apps have sucked for me after passing 40. I'm about to be 44 now. Haven't had a date in 5 months. No idea what's wrong with me. Its hard not to develop a victim mentality, and want to give up. Honestly, after the last stack up of rejections I'm starting to feel pretty worthless actually.