I used to have moderate AA, which I've all but completely conquered. The approach has become the easy part. Lucky for me, the club and bar area right by where I live plays overbearingly loud music everywhere, so all you need to get girls is looks and the confidence to approach. So I'm doing well with that....

But....

When I try day game (ie at the gym), I'm a babbling idiot with nothing to say. I just got back from the gym. I was warming up on the treadmill while some HB8.5 comes up and gets on the treadmill right next to me. About as straight forward IOI as can possibly be. So I talk to her and... blah blah "school...work...running...okay bye."

I got her number and told her to come out with me this weekend, and from there I am usually good. I'm actually a REALLY good talker when I have something substantiated to talk about.

My worry, though, is that I only got her because of looks. If she didn't come up to me and IOI-choke me, I wouldn't have approached b/c I had NOTHING to say.

And I've been this way forever, I just can't small talk...

So, PUAs. If you weren't a natural endearingly-smooth talker, what did you do to develop the skill?