It struck me recently that the redpill "culture" is in fact doing the exact opposite of what it claims to do : they are building a whole reality in their heads that has nothing to do with the physical one, going at it with the enthusiasm of 19th century anthropologist and pretty much the same results.

The posts are like "Well actually females prefer men with long toes, that is because historically women were not able to hunt and feed themselves and the only time they would eat fat was when a man would climb a tree to get some eggs from a nest, and that is what finally allowed their brains to devellop to near-male levels, and so females who were aroused by long toes chose partners who were better at climbing trees and they had a reproductive advantage. By natural selection today this is hardwired in their brains. It is not about your personality or your looks, it is the lenght of your toes." And the comments"- My dear esteemed colleague, what a striking insight ! May I add that it is probably the first phalanx that matters most ? As statistically, it will be the one less often lost, and so the one that impacts the most the overall lenght of the toe through one's life." "- Why thanks, this is genius ! You brilliantly completed my humble observations".

I am making up this (tame) example because there's no need to reshare some of the actually gross stuff, but I am not making up the general insanity neither everything being just plain wrong, wrong observations, wrong hypotethical premises, wrong causal links, wrong conclusion. They are in the wrong like soldiers of the Great War were in the mud, digging trenches in it, setting up little lodgings in it, eating and breathing and sleeping in it, and similarly few are coming back fully intact.