I just stumbled across this forum & have a basic understanding of what it's all about - would like some thoughts on my situation.

Have been with BD for nearly 4 years. This was his first committed relationship. I am 20, he is 22. He says he has been unhappy with us for the past 2 years. He's also been depressed since about 13. His brother is identical to him in personality & situation. I have spoken to his BM about their relationship & we broke up for exactly the same reasons.

Reason #1) They were unhappy and could never explain why. As much as both of us tried to do better and be better - it was never enough for either of them and they remained distant and closed off.

Reason #2) I can't fathom how I am supposed to be happy in a relationship where he does not communicate with me. I will admit to nagging him about opening up to me which apparently is a huge no-no. So, what is my option here? I have been a miserable wreck the past 3 years trying to understand this man and help him.

Reason #3) While both of us women worked consistently on improving ourselves for them, there was nothing we got in return. Personally, I completely overcame my anger issues thanks in large part to our relationship. He, however, has the exact same issues as in the beginning and shows no interest in getting better even though he admits to being miserable (so miserable that he nearly attempted suicide a year ago).

They were raised in a very traditional house and their mother is the kind of woman I'm sure you all aspire to be (I aspire to be too). BM and I both think that their issues stem from their parents marriage. Their dad had some serious issues expressing his feelings which resulted in a very miserable decade where they nearly divorced. He has since learned how to open up & is very affectionate towards his wife.

Since breaking up, I have retracted from him entirely even though it hurts and I still love him. I was the one who initiated the breakup. We will be living together as coparents but I have told him strictly no sex. I am tired of being disrespected & cast aside as an afterthought until he wants sex. He ignores me constantly for video games and makes me feel like shit about myself. He has no interest in my pregnancy.

So - thoughts. Is the situation salvageable? What are your suggestions? Naturally I want to have a family. But I also want to be respected. Is it my mindset that is wrong or is something inherently wrong with our relationship?