Maybe I'm not the only one getting confused when, if someone posts HV traits, some applaud it, others point out we shouldn't be applauding the bare minimum. I might have found a helpful thought experiment to differentiate.

If ALL MEN on earth would, say, be respectful and kind, be generous, initiate contact and plan thoughtful dates regularly... If literally everyone in your dating pool would behave like this. Would you still chose to date the guy you're thinking of? Why or why not?