Got friends who are your typical "I smash anything" kind of guys. How do you do this? How do you get into this mindset?

A bit about me, I'm 27, lost virginity at 26 with a girl who was cute but not really my type so I was not really attrated to her and we broke up after a few months. Went out with about 10 girls from bumble/tinder since then but didnt get past first date because I stopped making efforts since I was not attracted to them (they were cute enough to swipe right but not so much irl). Only went out with one girl I actually liked but it fizzled out, she was from a very religious/traditional family.

I think I'm an average guy 5/10. A bit skinny but workoung out, I socialize, I dont think I'm ugly but I also don't stand out. Also, inexperienced with women obviously. I wish I could get girls I find cute but I dont think thats an option, at least not right now. I want to date girls that are 4-5/10 but how do you guys do that? Like how do you actually get exited to take her home if you are not into her?