Yeah, first world problem I know, but if someone can relate...

So I'm a 6'4, Mediterranean-type guy, with an athletic body (broad shoulders, 4-pack abs and some shoulder/back definition) and an okay face. I think I've been called handsome by nearly all the middle-aged and old women from my family. When I discuss my struggles with girls, my friends don't understand how it happens to me because I'm supposedly so attractive!

The truth is, they think pussy literally falls in my lap, however I've never had girls giving me the "look" in public, or approaching me at parties or clubs.

I know I'm supposed to do some work to seduce on my part, I doesn't magically happen. But since I don't seem to get/see/detect girls' signals, I'm too afraid to approach. My mindset is something like "If she really wanted me to approach, she would've hinted at it".

TL;DR I find myself attractive, as do my friends and family, but I'm too afraid to act on it if girls don't show ultra obvious interest.