So, today I was casually browsing Reddit's front page when I came across this comic posted on Two X. Unsurprisingly, it addressed the issue of uneven household chores distribution through the lens is thirdwave feminism in a way that was clunky, without nuance, and man blaming, for all its good intentions. You can find the offending comic here: https://english.emmaclit.com/2017/05/20/you-shouldve-asked/amp/

I immediately thought of you ladies, and all that you taught me about taking responsibility for myself, and have a few comments on it I'd like to share.

Before I begin with my most major criticism I will note that I don't believe a household division of labor is a bad thing. I know some women and men that frequent here are very interested in having women be the masters of the domestic sphere while men provide financially. If that's the lifestyle you prefer, so be it. I certainly feel that having a man help around the house and in childcare is a reasonable expectation, especially if both partners are working to support the family.

The comic acknowledges that men are often not socialized to understand the importance of household duties and therefore do not readily offer assistance in then, often chastising overwhelmed partners with "why didn't you ask for help if you needed it?" or performing tasks incorrectly when delegated to do so. The underlying sentiment of the comic is that men need to be reprogrammed to automatically understand household needs and meet them without prompting from the woman.

I take serious issue with this. The comic defers to patriarchal causes behind household work imbalance, presenting women as victims of both the burden of the physical and mental workload associated with planning and performing tasks. It takes no time to even address the role of women's communication in the matter. If it is true that women are socialized to care more about practical tasks, why is it up to men to bridge the communication gap on something they haven't been socialized for? The very title of the comic insinuates that men are to blame for defending their "lack of participation" by requesting women to communicate their need for assistance. Are men supposed to just read the minds of women to understand what needs to be done when they've been raised not to prioritize household chores? The onus shouldn't be on men to adjust to the needs of women if the women are not even bothering to voice these needs.

Personally, I don't feel this is a major problem in my relationship, but that's because I am grateful for the other ways in which my captain's behavior complements mine. I am the major household planner, and I take pride in the task. It can get overwhelming, but my partner is incredibly supportive. I'm not with him because I expect him to match my fervor in planning. I'm with him because his awareness of my needs for a cuddle, a laugh, an orgasm, more food, or more sleep allows me to continue striving. He's the first to tell me when to step back and take care of myself.

Furthermore, even though I end up doing most of the planning, part of that is because I end up being neurotic about how tasks are executed. This means I'm the one keeping my captain from helping, by insisting tasks are completed my way, and I'm sure this is true of many women. If I want help, it's up to ME to step back and realize that if things don't get done exactly as I imagine them it is not the end of the world, or to provide specific instructions to my partner on what's needed, and trust that through patient communication he will understand. By choosing to take pride in my planning role, by being grateful for my partner's other relationship contributions, and by learning to step back and trust that everything will work out I don't end up harboring resentment. I'd recommend the same for women who identify too heavily with this comic.

A final unrelated note: the comic ends with a mention that household chores are not being done by men when women choose not to do them, but become the job of poor immigrant women. To that I say there is no shame in the honest work of cleaning, and in many cultures maids are not looked down upon, but treated with familiarity. The immigrant women who clean are filling a need and getting paid to do so, and if you feel their work is demeaning, then maybe it's time to reassess how we as a society treat maids, not further blame men.