I've met with a guy who is 185 cm on Reddit. We cold approached together a couple of times.

He's tall and I guess that works for him. Today, he got 2 numbers and with the last one, he kept shaking hands/holding hands for like a minute. And the girl was adoring him. 

That demoralized me so much.

I don't think I'm gonna meet with him anymore. 

How did he do that? Why it wasn't me but him?

Can something be wrong with me? Maybe I'm not that handsome? I'm 178 cm. I'm an average male. I only had one long term relationship from cold approach. I mean his face wasn't that great either.

Can it be strategies or tactics? I thought there was no need for any strategies and just being yourself was the best bet.

And I thought cold approaching women was creepy and didn't work???

Any ideas?