About one month ago, I fuck this girl from my university. She's objectively a 6.5 or a 7, wears little to no make-up, is very shy and bad at small talk, doesn't dress slutty, goes to church. In bed she's decent but nothing extraordinary.

We only ever meet for sex and keep fucking as fuckbuddies. She really likes it dirty: I apply the Sex God Method and man, it works with everybody but with her, even more. She really likes to be submissive to a dominant man that fucks her brains out. She told me she's never been fucked like this before, I make her try new things, yada yada.

So, the other day we're having post-sex talk and she asks me if I ever had a threesome. I lie (don't want to look more inexperienced than her) and say yeah, I had a MFM with a friend. She says she's had one too. I ask more about it and she says she got fucked by a guy, he came inside of her, then the other guy fucked her and came inside of her. I somehow hide my disgust, and am "in shock" for a few days. I shouldn't be, cause AWALT; but even for a TRP man it's easy to slip into lying to yourself.

She texts me 90% of the time, wants sex often but also tries to spend time with me outside of the bedroom... then this afternoon, out of the blue she texts me:

Her - Are you busy right now or can I talk to you about something for 2 minutes?

Me - Yeah go on

Her - We never really talked about it, so just to be clear - can we see other people or no?

Her - Don't be pissed, just honest please :P

Me - Of course

Her - Ok

Her - What about sex though?

Me - Isn't that what you just asked?

Her - Oh okay

At this point my disgust grows even more. It shouldn't, because AWALT and we're just fuckbuddies, I certainly haven't stopped looking for more pussy either. But these two episodes really destroyed the "Good girl" image she had which was a good part of my attraction to her.

As she didn't get much attention afterwards, she asked for when can we meet next time (not tomorrow, I'm actually busy) and she says it's a bummer having to wait until the weekend. As I ignore this, she says "Do I have to talk dirty for you to reply?"

Lessons learned:

  • Never assume a certain girl is a "good girl", they often are more fucked than others. AWALT. Carefully vet them over a very long period
  • Be careful not to lie to yourself subscionsciously, even if you're TRP-enlightened
  • Pratice abundance or you'll get "shocked" by discovering the naughty past of your fuckbuddies, instead of just laughing about it