When I was a teenager, I had a longtime girlfriend. We were very in love, the only reason why things didnt work out was because I had emotional problems when we lived together (i was like 18). But she was very beautiful, smart, not a hoe, and I moved across the country and she ended up marrying someone recently. We still txt every couple weeks as friends, and I have been with maybe 2 pretty attractive women since then.

I tried dating apps for a year or two, and recently met a girl through my business that I went out with a couple times.

It's so weird though, because I'm not the most buff dude or anything, but I am 6'2", 175 lbs, I have a blue collar business, live in a small town, and family and friends all pretty much tell me I'm a good looking dude and that basically no woman is out of my league at all.

This girl I have been seeing recently is kind of white trash, but I like her. I go to her families house and I shoot darts with her dad, I play with her kid and goof off and just have a fun time drinkin beers with everyone. I told her yesterday we should go out on another date just the two of us again soon, and her response was "I want to take things slow and not rush into a relationship". So...a polite rejection.

It's so weird to me though because these girls from apps and this current girl, whnever my friends or family meet them, they are kinda like "eh shes nice man, but you can do way better". But then I end up getting rejected/ghosted by these girls who everyone views as below my standards! So I honestly don't understand how aiming even HIGHER would result in any more success???

Even my attractive ex is like "stop going for these trashy girls, you are cute and smart and successful, they arent good enough for you". But I don't understand how that would work at all. What in the fuck am i missing? Bigger muscles? Tattoos? I don't get it.