What % of field reports on TRP do you think are fake?

Alpha_Kale · 2015-02-11T23:03:05+00:00

I think most of the stories are true but exaggerated.

If a guy goes home with a girl who is a 6/10 and fingers her, he'll say she was an 8/10 and they had sex. It's awfully telling that TRP insists 9/10 women are unicorns but every other success story on TRP is about an HB9.

Also, I think people look for what they want to see- so people will post tons of (true) stories about their CC-riding ball busting ex wife, but won't have any reason to mention all the decent women they meet in day-to-day because either it doesn't matter, or those women aren't HB9s so they don't count as women.

some_pill · 2015-02-11T23:46:10+00:00

I say a fair number were faked/embellished. Some are downright depressing. Like the feller that got beat up at a club and claimed it was a success. Complete detachment from reality.

Alpha_Kale · 2015-02-11T22:46:23+00:00

I bet there's a lot of fake stories. I bet there's a lot of true ones.

I have no doubt that TRP works for some men, on some women, some of the time.

That's not justification for the weird and wacky misogyny.

Every story on TRP could be true and it still wouldn't justify AWALT because of the obvious selection and confirmation bias at play, everyone else's observations that much of the world just doesn't work that way, and that even if it did, there is still no backing for the Evo psych obsession.

TRP is just so... Weird.

It's mind boggling that people believe it but obviously a good number do. Tin foil hats can be found in numerous corners of the internet.

zaphriel · 2015-02-12T00:47:12+00:00

75% bs. 20% part bs. 5% sadly true.

TheHeroReditDeserves · 2015-02-12T00:04:06+00:00

do I think are false? like almost all of them. I realize that its very likley that at least a few of them are true however all the ones that I have read are a best REALLY hard to swallow and at worst $100% present true stories that could have easily been straight x-posted from /r/thathappend

uangrydawg · 2015-02-12T02:48:03+00:00

shit niggas if i made reports on trp nobod belieb me. u cant make dis shit up happens to me

[deleted] · 2015-02-11T23:20:11+00:00

I assume everything on the internet is false until proven otherwise. Maybe that's just because I've been on 4chan for so long.

some_pill · 2015-02-11T22:53:39+00:00

What % of BP/feminist female reports of how "happy" their SOs are are fake or deluded?

We_Are_Legion · 2015-02-11T23:28:09+00:00

I had a read of the red pill yesterday, just to refresh myself.

This kind of thing seems prevalent:

I'm spinning 4 plates and advancing in my career. Life is great! (Yet I have time to sit on TRP giving long field reports and endless long responses to the field reports/posts of others)
I'm going to LTR one of my plates. She deserves it as she's busted her ass to be what I want.
I'm planning on staying with my girlfriend for the moment. She's bent over backwards to please me and has really stepped up.
A chick said this to me. And I said that to her. You should have seen her face. I walked away chuckling. Dumb whore.
woman on the dance floor (danish girl with huge tits of course) says I'm taller than her and have muscles and she likes that. Because I totally have muscles. Girls say it to me. See? I was "looking pretty damned good". Then she fucks me.
Charles Manson is a dark triad who pulls young chicks at age 80 and in jail!!! DoublePlus field report from the man himself! Then, much later, ohhhhh wait, turns out the chick was a psychopath herself who just wanted his body after his death.

To be fair, there was one field report I believed:

old married dude reports that he totally led his family on a day at disneyland. Sez this: "Even a woman who is better organized than the man should not lead. Even a woman who is smarter than the man should not lead. Intelligence is NOT the main factor in leadership. A steady hand is the most important thing. Women are mercurial. Their goals and objectives change depending on their mood, the time of month, the time of day, how they FEEL at that moment."

I don't know what might have happened if that dude wasn't there with his steady hand over his wife. She might have run off with Mickey Mouse or something!

speed3_freak · 2015-02-12T04:16:57+00:00

A bunch of them are written as if they are what a 17 year old would imagine would sound good. I don't read them anymore because I would say that if you take the time to write it down, you will automatically change some aspects to make it more entertaining and make you sound good.

However, I've absolutely seen the difference myself between me before TRP and after being introduced to TRP thinking. I would never write a FR though because who cares. It's like talking about your fantasy football team; you are really the only person that cares how you approached and got a number from that cute blond in line. Why would I waste my time like that?

M_rafay · 2015-02-12T09:17:21+00:00

20-30%. When I first started on forums like this I used to assign numbers like 90%, but when you actually start, there's no way to get around it: talking to girls isn't hard. And numbers game inevitably gives you unique experiences, that anyone'd reasonably want to talk about.

However I do think 90%+ is exaggerated, if not false.

[deleted] · 2015-02-11T23:16:22+00:00

I'm not so sure about FR's but I'm convinced a lot of the stories that generate karma are either made-up, exagerrated, or just a minority.

There was a series of indian wives being found out as sluts and alpha widows by their "beta" indian husbands through a sex tape. This story kept getting rehashed and reposted until finally people caught on.

I don't doubt that this happens a lot. Specifically there was a guy who claims to work as a bouncer for a high end Vegas club who witnessed girls being secretly dispensed non-alcoholic placebo keg and regardless of their being alcohol the girls still acted slutty. The guy got discredited because bits were not adding up in his story.

This inevitably brings us back to the issue of confirmation bias in TRP. TRP is occupied largely by beta males who, in being against promiscous behavior in women, will latch on to anything they regard as slutty and blow it up with sensationalism in order to get karma.

RedPill115 · 2015-02-12T05:35:17+00:00

I think some of them are fake and almost all of them are embellished.

The thing is, it's a bizarre day when you go out and try something red pill and it goes against everything you think you should be doing and it works.

I will never forget when I spent the evening doing push/pull, refusing to validate any opinion of a girl's that I liked, then at the end of the evening I walk her to her car and try to kiss her. She physically pushes me away... but doesn't leave. She keeps wanting to talk to me. I do it at least 2 more times. She physically keeps me from kissing her on the lips. So the last time I sorta start feeling bad long story short I walk away.

Now I'm going back to my room and feeling completely spent, and like a total jackass. I feel like I was a huge jerk, had done horrible things, etc. 5 minutes later she texts me - and tells me what a great time she had and how she wanted to hang out the next evening.

Feminism would have absolutely no doubt insisted that I was an evil shitlord rapist etc and that all girls thoughts that. And here instead the actual girl was going on about how great it was.

That's the difference between other stories and trp stories, you do have the opportunity to try them for yourself.

I found that being 100% trp does not work for me at all, but strong elements of it that I had thought were "bad" before do. And by "work" I mean like the above - the girl responds positively and enthusiastically.

[deleted] · 2015-02-11T23:43:08+00:00

It is too hard to tell. I personally lived some pretty "bullshit noway that happened" stories for me to really judge. Life is much stranger to fiction in my experience.

polyhooly · 2015-02-12T01:42:02+00:00

I reckon most probably have some grain of truth to them, but I think there is a lot of misinterpretation of the other parties' actions and reactions.

TheRedRustler · 2015-02-12T15:31:13+00:00

I don't put much weight into them because I know how easily it is to change the narrative or not know parts. If you read relationships you probably notice stories which paint the SO as a bad person but lack context, such as "he tells me he thinks of other girls having sex!" Which in reality he probably asked a question such as "I wonder how people over 400lbs have sex" or "my boyfriend is such an asshole!" When in reality he just told her he didn't feel comfortable with her going out clubbing alone.

GayLubeOil · 2015-02-11T23:19:07+00:00

What percentage of SJWs rape claims are fake?

autoNFA · 2015-02-11T22:40:46+00:00

I'm also interested in seeing which ones they consider real, especially those in which the narrator was not rejected.

Aerobus · 2015-02-11T23:28:17+00:00

Little are false. I wrote what could be called a FR recently, and a lot of people thought it was bullshit. That event actually happened in my life, and if the reaction to that was disbelief (from both sides of the aisle), I think people as a whole are not putting enough faith in FRs.

exit_sandman · 2015-02-11T23:21:31+00:00

A fair share of the stories are most likely embellished (a somewhat decent-looking woman becomes an 8, a slightly chubby one becomes a landwhale, the OP is casting himself in a very positive light etc.), but the content of the threads as such is more likely to be based on a true story than many of the attempts at creative writing with outrage porn-inducing potential one finds at /r/relationships.

VarsitySlutTeamCpt · 2015-02-12T04:23:15+00:00

All of them. Just like every BP stories are fake as well.

ECoast_Man · 2015-02-12T00:29:25+00:00

As a Rper, I think pure false is very low... Like the 5 per cent rage. I think embellished stories are in the 1/3rd range. Changing certain facts to guard against Doxxing is a given.

But yeah, not as high as other people. I just find it to be rare indeed someone would make an entirely fabricated story, and I think embellishment is more common. I dunno, I feel I can usually tell the truths from lies...

This is obviously my opinion though...

Title	What % of field reports on TRP do you think are fake?
Author	fizolof
Upvotes	7
Comments	123
Date	February 11, 2015 10:30 PM UTC (11 years ago)
Subreddit	Posted in /r/PurplePillDebate
Original Link	https://old.reddit.com/r/PurplePillDebate/comments/2vl4f5/what_of_field_reports_on_trp_do_you_think_are_fake/
Archive Link	https://theredarchive.com/r/PurplePillDebate/what-of-field-reports-on-trp-do-you-think-are-fake.283516 https://theredarchive.com/post/283516

Comments