As I mentioned in my original OKC post, I only signed up for OKC on 2 days ago, so I am no way an expert and this could all be utter crap, so YMMV. My sample size is also fairly small, I've sent out about 25 messages, had 14 replies and arranged 4 dates, as well as a hook-up. This is very much a beginner’s guide! If anyone has any additional advice, please let me know, I am all ears! Also, I will not post my profile, so don't ask, I may PM it though

Seddit Resources

A lot of what I am doing I took from posts here:

TofuTofu's post here is invaluable. It's basically a great summary of what a lot of things suggest, condensed into one post and from a seddit POV.

This post has some solid comments with some good advice

This post about openers is ok too

Not really a seddit resource, but read the OKC blog: http://blog.okcupid.com/ It's no longer updated, but the past information is solid

Profile

Your first port of call should be r/okcupid, especially it the Does and Don't for profiles. They also have people posting requests for critiques which I would highly recommend look through and taking what you can to improve your profile, luckily most people tag them with: [CRITIQUE]. Some things I tried to do, some of while will properly be covered in the other links:

  • Sell myself

Well, duh, right? Be honest, don't try too hard. Your profile should be congruent with your personality. A lot of the feedback I have been given in messages has matched what people say I am in IRL.

  • Avoid lists

Lists suck, they don't really express any real personality. Instead of listing your 110 of your favourite movies, talk about a few you really like, and why you like them. Put some feeling and emotion into, bitches love that.

In the 6 things i can't live without: air, oxygen, etc. are clichéd and NOT FUNNY.

  • Tell stories

The best way to DHV, as it is when opening sets IRL, is to drop in DHV naturally through telling stories.

  • Photos

Have awesome photos, and make sure you use My Best Face. Have no more than one picture of: wearing sun glasses, topless. Try for pictures that demonstrate what your hobbies are and appeal to what you are looking for. The CRITIQUE in r/okcupid can help to nail down what are and aren't good pictures. My main hobby is partying, social events, and fashion. Fashion as a hobby pays dividends, it's so easy to DHV, both in the profile, pictures and IRL as strangers always mentions, even guys, how well I dress.

  • Feedback

Once you are done, get feedback. Trying posting it in r/okcupid (I haven't done this myself yet as I am still working on mine), or as people you know. Most of my friends know what I get up to, and no one was surprised when I mentioned I had decided to try OKC. I have shared my profile with some girl friends, and gotten some solid feedback from them.

Messaging

Don't spam 100 girls with a generic message, that won't work. Aim for, short, tailored messages that raises something from their profile, maybe something you have in common, to girls with high % matches, followed with a hook/question/reason to message you back. r/okcupid has a link from their sidebar concerning messaging, and the comments are worth reading too: http://www.reddit.com/r/OkCupid/comments/js9x3/i_think_its_about_time_we_had_a_dodont_list_for/

A basic template I'm using:

Hi how's it going?

<<profile observation>>. <<hook/question>>

And that's pretty much it. Short, low investment, and requires them to reply to move things forward. An easy observation/question is asking if they like a band that is similar to one they mentioned. Think of them as situational openers, but instead of the current situation/venue you are currently in, base it on their profile.

I have gotten into the habit of using the Quick Matches, 4 staring anyone I would like to chat too and message them after they look at my profile. Some examples:

Girl has "I cry at books" in her most private thing to admit:

*I love The Road, I wouldn't say it made my cry though. What book do you love but struggle to read because you soak it with tears?"

Girl loves cooking:

We should have a cook off, with one specific ingredient. Let’s say, a banana, what would you make? :D

Girl lists Ian M Bank's as one of her favourite authors:

I love the Culture series, the scale of Excession blows my mind! If you were a Mind, what would you call yourself?

Answered that similar skin color was the same, was a 95% match

I was thinking we would have an awesome time hangout until, but I was browsing your questions and skin color is a concern! Do you also have a BNP membership? :P

Has since replied saying it was a mistake and we should hangout

In TofuTofu's post, he recommends mentioning your %'s. This is gold, gets such an awesome response. I like to use it on my second message.

I tried a neg messages, which ended up in this reply: "Negging doesn't work, Mr PUA". That was my only try with negish messages, I might try it again, but I didn't really feel comfortable sending the message in the first place, I don't really neg IRL, and I would rather stick to sending messages I am comfortable with.

Checking out the competition

I created a female account, somewhat similar to the kind of girls I am interested it, and had a look at what the competition is. This allowed me to tweak accordingly, and possibly from the messages people send, see what are people are using. I am hoping to not see too much penis....

And that's about it. Nothing special, all fairly newbie. If I am doing anything really dumb, please let me know!