I'm at an intermediate level in pickup, and lately, I’ve been questioning some of the advice from a dating coach I follow. He’s been helpful in many ways, and often his tips are spot-on. But other times, I’m not sure if his advice makes sense for me personally.

When I approach women, I get a range of responses. Some women show interest and start engaging, while others don’t seem interested (either they don't invest in the conversation or directly say they’re not interested). I’m not getting terrible results that would make me worry that my approach sucks.

However, this coach once said that, as long as she doesn't have a boyfriend, it’s always possible to sleep with any woman, no matter her current life situation. Doesn't matter if she’s already in a get-to-know phase with someone else, doesn't matter if I'm not her type, doesn't matter if she is going through lots of stress, doesn't matter if she recently got divorced — it all doesn’t matter. According to him, if I don’t succeed in getting the girl, IT’S ALWAYS MY FAULT. I must have done something wrong, every single time. So if I approach a woman who isn’t showing interest, he insists I should stay in the set, tease her for not investing, handle her objections, and keep going.

Sometimes, I try this. But often, if I notice she seems uninterested, I prefer to walk away, as I don’t see the reward in pushing if she’s not receptive. Other times, I’ll stay a bit longer and try to be persistent until she engages more. Occasionally, this has led to some numbers, but many times, she’ll flake before the date or goes cold quickly after the date. And when that happens, the coach still insists that I must have done something wrong or didn’t build enough attraction etc.

I see a similar split in this community—some people share this coach's perspective of “stay persistent; you can get any woman if you say and do the right things.” Others suggest only focusing on women who show genuine interest from the start.

What are your thoughts on this? I’m starting to feel like this “always stay persistent, it’s your fault if she’s not interested” mindset is really messing with my head big time. After two or three minutes of teasing and calling her out, if she’s still not interested or declines the close, dafuq else is there to do?