I notice a lot of redpillers saying things like "all men care about is that she's hot and not annoying", "women's SMV is all about their looks", "the only thing I'm looking for in a partner is that she's hot and has a low N", "men would rather have a boring 9 than a 7 with a great personality."

I also notice a lot of redpillers complaining that the girls they interact with are stupid, shallow, prone to flaking on dates, constantly on their phones, obnoxious, unwilling to sacrifice things to make them happy, entitled, or otherwise unpleasant to be around.

These seem to me to be related.

Half of people are smarter than average, half are dumber; half are kinder than average, half are crueler; half are more interesting than average, half are duller. If your only selection criterion is "she has to be a 9", then half the time you're going to wind up dating someone who is below average on other criteria, and you're going to find yourself interacting with a lot of terrible people.

Except the situation is worse than that, because all the kind smart funny 9s are snapped up rather quickly, while all the cruel stupid unfunny 9s are left complaining that there are no good men left.

On the other hand, if TRPers as a whole decided to take a holistic approach to dating, to say "I'm going to prioritize finding someone who has good character and whom I enjoy spending time with, even if they are less attractive", they would spend more time interacting with nonterrible women and have a better opinion of women.