I wonder if we can measure how "attractive" chastity is?

Assume four different women make a relationship desirable for you.
First one is a virgin.
One of them is quite chaste herself. She proclaims she only had sex with long distance boyfriends (consider how many they should be in her age range) in her life, and to the best of your experience and judgment she can't possibly have a high count nor cock mileage.
The third one is a regular girl. As experienced as she should be. None more, none less. She proclaims she had boyfriends (consider how many are average) and hooked up for some time (consider the average too).
The last one didn't have reservations against sex, she fucked a lot.

These women have personalities fitting the backgrounds, all will be loyal. How must their attractiveness (not only looks, the whole sex appeal) be compared to others for them to be picked?
Not my answer, I'll leave mine as a comment.

Just put 1/2/3/4 and leave a "x" for herself. I guess I should leave an example of answer.

Virgin: x/0/0/-1
(The virgin will be picked if she's as attractive as the other two, or minus one on a ten scale compared to the last)
Inexperienced: +0.1/-/0/-1
(The inexperienced must be more attractive than the virgin to be picked, will be picked if she's as attractive as the average one, and will be picked even if she's -1 on the 10 scale worst than the hot one.