We like to make fun of guys on this sub for demanding a virgin, in large part because it's not realistic and seems more like a fetish than anything (yes, I've seen the infidelity statistics, but I've also spent enough time talking with bros to know that that isn't REALLY why guys fantasize about virgins).

So here's my question. If you were in a relationship with a quality partner you trusted and had a good sex life with, how would you respond if he had a kink where he wanted to pretend like it's your first time? Just asking you to act like you don't know what you're doing and are nervous and insecure for a night. Would you go along with it one time? Would it creep you out and be a red flag? Or would you just politely decline but keep the relationship going as normal?