Since this obnoxious argument gets tossed around too often, I want to see real opinions (especially from women).

I believe I could categorize it like this, for the sake of realism:

Only wants a virgin gf/wife - 10%

Cares enough to be vocal - 35%

Cares, but not vocal - 40% (this includes men who plug their ears or bury their head in the sand, the ignorance is bliss approach)

Doesn't really care but still would never date a prostitute (or obscenely high n woman) - 10%

Legitimately does not care at all and would date a prostitute - Somewhere around 1-2% of men

In my scenario, I believe around 98% of men care about n count on some level.