I read a comment by another user and I think he made a really good point that I've been thinking about.

There’s so many distractions now (porn, video games, tv) that weren’t there in there past that can cause a lot of us on here (imo) to miss out or ignore the struggles that help us level up in life since we chase those instead due to different reasons (being introverted, being bullied, having a traumatic experience, being unlucky, being neuro-divergent, having the wrong mindset towards socializing for too long, developing unhealthy coping strategies, being legitimately deformed, undiagnosed mental issues, etc.) - Shortfingers

I bring this up as a person who is introverted, studied STEM, has very solo-oriented hobbies like gaming, reading, writing, taking care of my dog, etc. (and also deal with some of the issues he described as well to some extent). It's almost like a mathematical law, that if you are introverted, you have an exponentially higher chance towards being single for longer periods of your life, for both men AND women, because you just don't meet nearly as many people over the course of a year, or a decade. Maybe you only have one, two, or three close friends or something, and no social media presence, and no OLD profile, and no linkedin, and especially if you and your friends are all a bunch nerds who do things that the vast majority of women, and to some extent other men, think are lame and goofy like grinding the ranked ladder in a video game or reading manga books.

I wish people were more honest about this, especially to younger men who are introverted. Your hobbies and your lifestyle affect your dating life massively. Being in college is a CHEAT CODE that lasts 4-6 years. College is like living on an island full of young women who are all single and are all free from parental supervision for the first time. It is not real life. It is a resort you pay to stay at for 4 years, that also serves as a check on the box socially to be considered "upper class" later on. After you graduate at 22-24, or 18 if you never went to college, if you are a man and your life looks like this:

  1. Wake up.
  2. Go to work, with all male nerds because you are a STEMboi or a plumber or something.
  3. Go home from work.
  4. Get drunk / high by yourself and play 8 hours of Magic the Gathering and some video games with your online clan and have a good ol' epic fucking introverted time.
  5. Maybe hang out with your 1-3 introverted gamer buddies IRL who don't know any girls either.
  6. Do some other introverted hobby like write your fantasy space epic adventure novel.
  7. TV YouTube Twitch binge / Sleep.
  8. Repeat.

...you're probably single if I had to guess, and you're going to stay that way, for a long time. OLD could be the solution, but many of you don't even try to use OLD. And OLD won't help you if you're not quite muscular, which many introverted nerds are NOT. Most are either scrawny, or fat, and I'm not sure which one is better than the other, or if either one is better (I'd be interested to get opinions on this from women).

All of my past relationships / hookups have happened because:

  • A girl in highschool knew someone I knew and was interested in me (short relationship).
  • A girl I knew since elementary school randomly wanted to hook up with me after we graduated highschool (twice).
  • A girl I was friends with set me up on a date with her friend (6 month relationship).
  • I met a girl at an event at a casino from a job we both got hired for at school (short relationship).
  • I ran into a girl in the hallway at school and we just so happened to be looking for the same class (2+ year relationship).
  • Also, making out with different girls at parties just because I found my way into them.

The common theme is that I had social proof. All you need as far as social proof goes, for the most part, as long as you're not extremely off putting and cringe, is a shared class, or a mutual friend, or a party invitation, that's literally it! A lot of guys don't even have that and much of it is because you either have no "life", or your life involves no women.

  • Your workplace is 100% men.
  • Your friend group is 100% men and that's like, 33% each.
  • You do not go out to bars / clubs and if you do you do not socialize.
  • You do not go to the gym and if you do you do not socialize.
  • You do not go to church and if you do you do not socialize.
  • You do not go anywhere at all and you socialize with the same 0-4 people for like 3-10 years.
  • You do not go to any hobbies that involve women AT ALL.
  • You do not hang out with anybody who does these things, AT ALL.

If you are a stranger to everyone on the planet you might as well be an alien. It's become incredibly easy for introverts to turn to a very hermetic lifestyle in our culture because of remote work, entertainment streaming, online competitive gaming, and pornography. This includes people like me, who are introverted but have always had a social circle of friends, and would consider myself as usually pretty funny, and have been considered the same by many others as well, over my life. I can hold a conversation and I'm not socially anxious. You may have found, as I have found, that over time, your interests and your life course have lead you down a path where you never extend yourself outside your home base, into the society, at all.

This is a problem. If your social circle shrinks down to small enough, or if it implodes to zero, it's incredibly hard to get that engine running again. Relationships are things that generally chain into one another, like Yu-Gi-Oh cards, so if you run low on them, it's hard to replace them, especially as an adult. A lot of "hikkikomori" / "NEET" types (not in education, employment, or training / asocial shutins, video game addicts, agoraphobes, depressed, etc) are people who's social life simply fell off of the wagon, or never got going at all, because it's simply easy to let it all fall apart, and be alone, and do alone-things. Having friends, and partners is now optional, that means you have to work for it. And it's difficult to work for it when you don't know where to do that, and it's especially hard if you truly love your introverted lifestyle and your nerdy all-male hobbies, and your goofy all-male friends, and your nerdy computer-chair bound remote tech job that you work, on the same PC you use to play MMO's and watch anime all night long without anyone around.

I'm not sure what the solution to these men's problems are or if there is one, aside from forcing yourself to stop doing the things you enjoy, to do something you won't enjoy, just to be around people who might like you. It's a tough position to be in, being an introvert, in an atomized world where people are disproportionately benefitted by being extroverted by temperament. People who live like this have often been living like this for a long time and it's hard to create a roadmap out of it, and many people choose not to, yet desire to still find love, somehow. I'm sure this makes up a large portion of the reddit demographic, as far as men on subs like these goes. I've seen other posts about how people being asocial is one of the primary roots of the struggle men face in relationships nowadays, and I can only speak on behalf of men, it's probably true for women too.

EDIT*: I don't know why but it seems like a mod or someone changed my flair from "discussion" to "cmv". Not sure what that's about. I'm not here to debate with people to try to "win" or change people's outlooks, I'm just finding new perspectives and advice and listening to people's personal stories and sharing ideas about all of this and how it's related to me personally.*

EDIT 2: This post blew up pretty far beyond what I expected. Messages are coming in faster than I can respond to them. Thanks everyone for the discussions I'll keep reading and chiming in where I can.