Do we always have to try being somebody who we actually aren't? It seems like "just be yourself" is only viable when "yourself" is good enough to attract.

Blue pill tells you that you have to be the extroverted social butterfly guy whose charisma and confidence are through the roof. For example, whenever somebody talks about short guys having difficulty in dating, there's always that one "oh but I know a short guy who pulls like crazy because he's so content with everyone" response... or something somewhat similar. You get my point. It's always those same personality traits.

Red pill tells you to become an alpha male and have "game". Again, it's just telling men to have some set of traits to attract women.

It's almost like men have to be a specific type of person to be loved. Like society is some sort of "sculptor" who takes rocks, which all have different shapes, and turns them into the same exact shape. Women can afford to be introverted, shy, nerdy or like gaming. She will still have men who love her for who she is, and even if she is struggling, nobody will suggest her to change who she is. But men? No. Those are negative traits and they need to be changed. Otherwise, he's doomed to be a loner. In RP terms, he MUST have the alpha male energy.